English Language Teachers' Experiences of Conducting Action Research: An Interpretive Study
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Kathmandu University School of Education
Abstract
The production and practice of carrying out action research (AR) on the teaching
learning classroom-related problems at school was one of the major criteria in work
performance appraisal forms, especially used in provisions relating to promotion
given in the Teacher Service Commission regulation (Government of Nepal [GoN],
2000). Teachers will receive 5 marks out of 100 for preparing a research report on
improving their teaching practice in their subject. Teacher Competency Framework
also mandates public school teachers to prepare at least one research report and
submit it to the school and local level along with the form (National Center for
Educational Development [NCED], 2015a). Multiple studies have explored action
research as a tool for teachers’ professional development. However, so far, none of
the research has been found on the practice of preparing and carrying out AR in
public schools in Lumbini Province, which requires teachers’ commitment,
institutional support, and clear policy guidelines for teachers' and students’ learning.
Therefore, this research aimed to explore the experiences and perceptions of
permanently appointed teachers who are required to submit action research to the
school, local level, and Education Development and Coordination Unit.
The study employed an interpretive qualitative approach to study the
participants' perceptions and holistic experiences of the issue. This study purposively
selected three secondary English language teachers, their head teachers, and the
Education Officer of a municipality in Lumbini province. I conducted semi-structured
interviews with the participants to get in-depth information and experiences on the
selected issue. In the same way, field notes and document analysis were also used as
tools for data collection. The theoretical ground of this study was the Sociocultural
Theory of Vygotsky, which incorporated the Zone of Proximal Development,
scaffolding, dialogic processes, and mediation tools that played a pivotal role in
learning. This study employed a thematic approach in data analysis that initially
transcribed, read, reread, coded, and categorized the data, following the developing
themes outlined in Saldana (2016), before presenting, interpreting, and analyzing the
data and discussing the results.
The findings explored the discrepancy between the provision and practice of
AR. All participants perceived the importance of AR for professional, promotional,
and learning achievement. However, insufficient research skills, inadequate facilities,
an unfavourable research environment, bias in evaluation, unsystematic promotion,
inspection rather than supervision and monitoring, and workload were barriers to
producing AR based on instructional problems. They also complained about the
unavailability of training, resources, and mentoring, as well as the monitoring system
for motivation in innovation and research. Similarly, head teachers blamed teachers
for preparing action research within an hour without exploring real issues. Therefore,
producing action research by schoolteachers was not efficient; it needed teachers’
dedication, commitment, institutional support mechanisms, and practical policy.
Based on the theory, it was clear that AR was practitioners' research that was
easy and cost-effective to carry out in the area where problems occurred and that
solved the problem dramatically in a very short period of time. Although participants
perceived that it facilitates teachers’ professional development and promotes
students’ learning outcomes, they have not been able to carry out and implement it
due to workload, inadequate knowledge, biased evaluation of AR, and insufficient
resources. Based on this study, future researchers can explore how action research
can be directed toward self-reflective inquiry rather than compliance-oriented in
schools using direct classroom observation tools and focus group discussions.
